Lot Essay
The largest examples with this border design tend to have complete cartouches in the border while the medium sized and smaller examples have the part-cartouches, as seen here. The best known of the larger carpets is probably that in the Bargello Museum in Florence (Carlo Maria Suriano, "Patterns Of Patronage, Classical Carpets in the Bargello Museum, Florence", Hali 83, October/November 1985, pp.84-85 and pl.9). The footnote to that entry (note 18, p.116) gives details of twelve other comparable examples. There are similarly a few slightly smaller examples, the best of which is generally acknowledged as that which was formerly part of the Ghazi Aita Collection which sold in these Rooms, 18 October 2001, lot 220. Others from the medium sized group include one with a green ground border which was with Bausback in Mannheim (Hali 107, November/December 1999, advertisement p.49), another with much stiffer drawing in the Museum für Angewandte Kunst, Vienna (Hali 42, November/December 1988, p.30), and a further but very worn example in the Jim Dixon Collection, California (Hali, 109, March/April 2000, p.101). The border of the present lot is typical of the group with smaller proportions where the cartouches are bisected clearly on the central vertical axis. This wonderful 'Lotto' rug is particularly attractive as it uses a more unusual colour palette than most within the border, with the inclusion of a warm terracotta and a shaded sea-green.
The earliest of the group can be dated to the middle of the sixteenth century on the basis of a painting by Jacopo del Ponte in Rome dateable to around 1560 which appears to show the half cartouche version of this border (Mills, op.cit., p.282, no.16). The same border appears with greater regularity immediately after 1600 in paintings from the Netherlands and England (Mills, op.cit.nos.28-30). The majority of paintings after 1600 however appear to show a greater number of smaller rugs, many of which are displayed on tables. A very similar example with the same field design and border pattern but with a different palette within the cartouches was displayed recently in Venice in the highly successful exhibition, 'Serenissime Trame, Carpets from the Zaleski Collection and Renaissance Paintings', Venice, 2017, exhibition catalogue, p.127, pl.20.
The earliest of the group can be dated to the middle of the sixteenth century on the basis of a painting by Jacopo del Ponte in Rome dateable to around 1560 which appears to show the half cartouche version of this border (Mills, op.cit., p.282, no.16). The same border appears with greater regularity immediately after 1600 in paintings from the Netherlands and England (Mills, op.cit.nos.28-30). The majority of paintings after 1600 however appear to show a greater number of smaller rugs, many of which are displayed on tables. A very similar example with the same field design and border pattern but with a different palette within the cartouches was displayed recently in Venice in the highly successful exhibition, 'Serenissime Trame, Carpets from the Zaleski Collection and Renaissance Paintings', Venice, 2017, exhibition catalogue, p.127, pl.20.